Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Critical Essay: Stage 2

While it may seem as though the removal of Copyright laws will allow for a more active expansion and development of ideas, the success of the Copyleft and Free Culture movements will in reality instigate an utter termination to the creation of any and all new ideas and plunge the American economy into depression.

It may be true that before the 1700’s when copyright laws were enacted, authors could use other authors’ works as their own and build on top of existing ideas, which may have even resulted in a better work than the original. Then again, is this reformatting of borrowed work really the author’s own work? Either way, the value of the work is depreciated no matter how it has been improved from the original work just by the mere fact that it is not the author’s original work. Some may argue that because Geoffrey Chaucer based so many of his tales in The Canterbury Tales on previously existing stories and improved upon them, he was able to write a masterpiece that was widely accepted by lower and middle class individuals and that he is known as the Father of English Poetry because of this work. Moreover, the sole purpose of The Canterbury Tales is to retell stories the pilgrims told, so he was in a way restricted to use the pilgrims’ stories whether they were already existing stories or not. However, could he have written a better piece if he had not incorporated other authors’ ideas into his work?

There is still a potential flaw in original works. In John Donne’s Holy Sonnets, his original style of writing and use of unorthodox, abstract metaphors baffled many of the less educated lower class commoners and made it less relatable to them. However, it is because of this originality and uniqueness that his sonnets became so popular and was preserved throughout history. In the end, a completely original work has the potential to always be better than a work created by improving upon existing ideas.

Students for Free Culture and the Copyleft Movement believe that allowing free access to works such as music, software, and other arts will promote “creativity and innovation.” Both those notions are wrong. True creativity cannot be obtained by merely copying another author’s work and adding a few new thoughts on top of it. First of all, altering a work from its original form causes the piece to lose its original purpose, the soul embodying the work, which then makes it completely meaningless—every line, every word, every comma, the author put there for a reason. Secondly, allowing users to base their work on a previously existing work hinders them from tapping into the full extent of their creativity and deprives them of the opportunity to explore into the uninhabited chambers of their mind and unlocking the potential ideas they would not otherwise have been able to think of. Antonio Vivaldi, a baroque classical music composer, has been accused of reusing phrases from his previous pieces and repeating the same patterns in all his works. Although he possesses a very unique style and has written many great pieces of music, all his pieces are unique and great in the same way, which diminishes the uniqueness and greatness of each piece. Nonetheless, it is true that every person must have a place to start from, but in order to create something that is truly creative, they must take a leap from what already exists, into the world of unknown and trust that they are capable of creating something new and magnificent, as Beethoven did in the finale movement of his ninth symphony—something never before heard yet miraculous. In actuality, free access constricts the vast creativity that humans possess; copyright laws impel authors to become independent of existing ideas and create something completely new.

As for innovation, not only will free access impose an abrupt halt on innovation and culture, as it does with creativity, it will plunge the world into depression as well. Similar to the philosophies promoted by Communists where wealth and property is shared among the entire population, the idea of free access promoted by the Free Culture Movement and Copyleft where music, software, and other arts are shared among the entire population is bound to fail as well. Despite the fact that Communism leaves a vulnerable gap for corruption, because everyone shares equal wealth, people have no motivation to work for themselves, which proves detrimental to the economy; the same consequences will result from the idealistic concept of free access. Supporters of the Copyleft movement believe that if a work could be accessed, distributed, and modified for free, individuals will be free to improve upon the work followed by rapid innovation of the work. Conversely, who will buy the original product if there is a new and improved version of it distributed online for free? If music, software, and other arts are made available for free on the internet, as the Students for Free Culture advocate, what company will spend thousands of dollars producing a product just to have it thrown on the internet for free? Companies will stop producing software, which serve as a critical starting point for individuals to improve upon; individuals are limited to making small improvements over old software created by companies before they inevitably go out of business; the absence of new products and significant technological discoveries achieved only by the large amounts of research that only large companies can sponsor cause technological advancement to come to a halt, which leads to the destruction of the American economy and a world-wide depression. If allowed to succeed, the Students for Free Culture and Copyleft movement will destroy all culture, creativity, innovation, and the world economy.

Copyright laws help promote creativity and the development of new ideas. One company produces a new product that consumers want to buy, and because other companies cannot use the same idea, in order to stay on the market, other companies must spend more money researching and developing different, even more advanced products that will surpass the first. This gives rise to competition between large companies resulting in better products at lower prices and a greater expenditure in research and development. The economy prospers and propulsion for improved higher education will follow to supply skilled scientists and researchers to keep up with the rapid advancement of technology.

No comments:

Post a Comment